The Best Shoulder Holsters For Your Handguns: Leather & Nylon Holster Reviews

If you are looking to buy a shoulder holster, chances are that you’ve already cleared out the requirement to conceal carry in your state and you want something that will be functional and also be made with the highest quality possible for the price.  Finding the right shoulder holster can not only depend on the gun you have, but personal preference will come into play when it comes to both look and feel.

Before we break out our favorite brands and models, let’s start with the fact that Galco brand is one of the top manufacturers for any type of holster on the market, period.

You’ll see two others mentioned below, but when it comes down to it, buying a Galco is a wise investment and shouldn’t ever let you down.  It just comes down to if you can justify the price, and we understand that every person’s budget is different.  The holster buying process isn’t unlike any other process like buying a gun safe or the right optics choice for your rifle.

If you don’t feel like a full read, then just take a look at our comparison table, or click THIS LINK(where we’ve done the sorting for you) and check out what people are saying online about most of Galco’s holsters depending on the model you are looking for.

For more information on our favorite types of shoulder holsters for some of the most popular guns out there, check out the detailed reviews we’ve rounded up for you below.  We’ve got a table with our favorite models plus a more in depth dive in the review details below.

Our Comparison Chart:

PictureNameFirearm UseHandednessPrice
Galco Miami Classic Shoulder System for 1911 5-Inch Colt, Kimber, Para, Springfield (Tan, Right-hand)Most 1911'sModel Specific Right/Left$$$
Gould & Goodrich B804-G17 Gold Line Shoulder Holster (Black) Fits GLOCK 17, 19, 22, 23, 31, 32, 34, 35, 39Glock 17/19/22/23/31/32/34/35/39Model Specific Right/Left$$
Galco Jackass Rig Shoulder System for Sig-Sauer P226, P220 (Havana, Right-hand)Sig P226/P220Model Specific Right/Left$$$
UTG Deluxe Universal Horizontal Shoulder Holster, Black (Havana, Right-hand)UniversalUniversal$


Our Favorite Shoulder Holster For a 1911 Handgun:

There aren’t many models on the market for a 1911 that can hold a candle to the build price and quality of the The Galco Miami Classic Shoulder System for 1911’s.  Let’s take a look at the pros and cons.


  • The design has been in production since the 1970’s. It’s tried and tested
  • Full leather construction that’s flexible enough to fit most standard 1911’s
  • Comes in Black or Tan Finish
  • Magazine Pouch on the opposite side of the holster
  • Galco’s Reputation
  • Even Weight Distribution


  • Pricier than some other manufacturers.
  • May not fit 1911’s with tactical rails (Sig Sauers)
  • May not fit 1911’s with tactical lights

Overall the Miami Classic is a stalwart and it’s worth the build price.  There aren’t many other holsters that you can buy that have the same features and flexibility that the Miami Classic has. Your best bet if the price wards you off is to take a look at some of the knock offs that might be similar in construction but not made to the same standards that Galco Produces.  For our 1911’s, there’s not another model we’d take over this particular model.

Our Favorite Shoulder Holster for the Glock 17/19/22/23/31/32/34/35/39:

Did we get every Glock model?  Not quite, but the Gould & Goodrich B804-G17 will do the job for every model listed.  The B804-G17 Gold Line Holster fits many of today’s popular Glock models snugly and we will highlight the pros and cons of each.


  • Top Grain Leather Manufacturing
  • Holds the most commonly carried Glock Models
  • Made in the United States
  • Usually Priced around $100.00
  • Made specifically for Glocks so specialization
  • Double Ammo Carrier on the Opposite Side


  • Only Available in Black
  • Only fits Glocks

There aren’t too many cons with the GoodRich B804-G17.  If you own any of the Glock Models we’ve mentioned, you can pick this up with confidence that it will fit your application and do what you need it to do every time.

Our Holster Pick for the Sig-Sauer P226/P220 Enthusiast:

This falls in line with the 1911 camp as we fall back to Galco on this one.  The Jackass Shoulder Rig System made for right handers is extremely quality just like the Miami Classic.  Let’s look at the Pros & Cons:


  • Closer fit than the Miami Classic
  • Quality you expect from Galco
  • Even Weight Distribution
  • Ammunition/Magazine Pouch
  • Suede straps enhance comfort


  • Price – Usually just under $150.00
  • Magazine Pouch may not hit 20 round Magazines

As with any product made by Galco, you can expect a quality build that will last you for years.  This is an absolutely great pickup if you own a P226 or P220 and expect to carry it on a daily basis.

The Top Universal Shoulder Holster For Anyone on a Tight Budget:

The UTG Deluxe Universal Shoulder Holster is one of the most purchased  on the market today.  Bottom line here is that there’s no better holster for the price if you are looking to pay less than 30.00 on a shoulder holster.  Remember, that the quality here while better than other cheap models, will usually not withstand the years of abuse that a leather holster will hold up through.  Let’s take a look at the pros and cons in detail.


  • Cost – Under $30.00 in most cases!
  • Universal Fit – will fit almost all types of handguns
  • Ammunition carrier on the opposite side of the firearm
  • Allows for both left and right hand shooters
  • Padded Shoulder Harness
  • Light Weight
  • Shoulder pads help balance and weight distribution


  • Build Quality Compared to Leather

I’m sure we could harp on some of the other items that some folks would classify as cons (holster discoloration, elastic bands, lower quality materials) but honestly what do you expect when you spend $30.00 or less on a holster?  If you aren’t the type of person expecting to get 10+ years out of what you buy, than the UTG Deluxe is a pretty solid buy.  Just make sure your expectations are set correctly up front.

Wrap Up:

We hope you’ve enjoyed our breakdown and that our advice helps you decide what brand or model will best fit your needs.  Obviously anytime you do a full breakdown article like this you are bound to miss someone’s favorite, so if you feel like we didn’t do justice to a model that’s out there, please feel free to drop us a line so we can update our guide.

Overall we feel like these are some of the best models you can buy for the money and you won’t be unsatisfied with any of them holding your handgun.